Why men rape in Asia – UN study
Nearly one in four men surveyed in the Asia-Pacific region admitted raping a woman or girl, according to the first multi-country study on the prevalence of rape and partner violence and the reasons behind it [ http://www.partners4prevention.org ].
While the prevalence of reported rape of non-partners was high across the Asia-Pacific, sexual violence against female partners was more widespread, according to the UN study, which interviewed some 10,000 men and 3,100 women in Bangladesh, Cambodia, China, Indonesia, Sri Lanka and Papua New Guinea (PNG) between 2010-2013.
Rather than being asked whether they had committed rape or violence against women, the men were instead asked: “Have you ever forced a woman who was not your wife or girlfriend at the time to have sex?” and “Have you ever had sex with a woman who was too drugged to indicate whether she wanted it?”
Responses in PNG showed the highest rate of violence against women in the region, with about 62 percent of the men interviewed there indicating they had raped a woman.
Some men reported experiencing rape by other men as adults.
The lowest prevalence of male rape, 2 percent, was found in the Indonesian cities of Jayapura, capital of Papua Province, and Jakarta, the national capital, while the highest, at 8 percent, was in Bougainville, PNG.
The autonomous region of Bougainville in PNG was devastated by a violent civil war – among the longest and bloodiest in the Pacific – between separatist rebels and the government from 1989-1998.
Thousands of residents, some 10 percent, died in the conflict, in which rebels and government forces alike reportedly “used rape, humiliation and forced marriage as war tactics”, according to a 1997 Amnesty International report.
Interviews conducted by the UN Development Fund for Women (UNIFEM) in 2003 [ http://www.peacewomen.org/portal_resources_resource.php?id=571 ] indicated criminal groups used the conflict to justify rape. A nun told UNIFEM that life for women during the conflict was like living “between two guns”.
In the years following the conflict, women continued to feel threatened by weapons still in circulation, according to one local development agency cited by UNIFEM.
But even outside this bloody theatre of war, and years later, the situation remains grim for women.
“The problem is bad. We pretend that it is not there,” head of the Family and Sexual Action Committee, a government programme set up to address gender violence, said [ http://www.irinnews.org/report/95030/papua-new-guinea-gender-based-violence-left-untreated ].
The country’s National Executive Council (similar to a cabinet) has endorsed a Family Protection Act, which is currently before parliament. It would criminalize domestic violence and strengthen 2009 legislation prohibiting violence against children [ http://www.unicef.org/png/FBO_Manual_Part_4.pdf ] and enforcing protection orders.
The deputy chairwoman of the independent National Commission on Violence Against Women, which was founded by the government of Indonesia, said that gender violence in Indonesia remains widespread, even after the government issued legislation to protect women; a 1984 law bans discrimination against women while a 2004 law criminalizes domestic violence.
“The men’s admission is the tip of the iceberg,” said the deputy chairwoman. “Very few men are honest enough to admit they have committed rape.”
The commission recorded more than 216,000 cases of violence against women in 2012 (the country has an estimated 118 million women [ http://indonesiadata.co.id/main/index.php/jumlah-penduduk ]), with at least 20 women being raped daily in Indonesia, she said. And these are only incidents reported to authorities.
Women in Indonesia are often resigned to the dominant cultural perspective on gender violence.
Many victims choose not to report because of family pressure, and sometimes because communities put the blame on them. Police often have to release perpetrators of sexual violence at the request of their wives and partners.
Law enforcers also apply outdated definition of rape requiring evidence such as blood and semen.
The majority of men cited in the UN study who perpetrated rape, especially marital rape, did not report any legal consequences. Marital rape was the most common form of rape, according to the study, but is not criminalized in many of the countries studied; gang rape was the least common form of rape admitted by respondents.
The most common motivation perpetrators gave for rape was a sense of sexual entitlement – the belief that men have a right to sex with women regardless of consent (73 percent of respondents). More than half said it was for entertainment (53 percent), while alcohol, often assumed to be a common trigger for violence, was the least common response.
Men who had themselves been victimized – abused, raped or otherwise sexually coerced – were more likely to commit rape than those who were not, the study found. Past violence toward a partner, having paid for sex or having had many sexual partners were all associated with increased likelihood of raping a non-partner.
A researcher at Partners for Prevention, a joint programme of the UN Development Programme, the UN Population Fund, UN Women (the successor of UNIFEM) and the UN Volunteers programme in the Asia and the Pacific, based in Bangkok, Thailand, that conducted the survey, wrote in the UK medical journal The Lancet [ http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS2214-109X(13)70074-3/abstract ]: “Surprisingly, our results show that although some overlap exists, physical and sexual violence do not always appear to be committed together, or for the same reasons, in different regions.”
In the same journal [ http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS2214-109X(13)70069-X/abstract ] Rachel Jewkes of South Africa’s Medical Research Council concluded: “In the view of the high prevalence of rape worldwide, our findings clearly show that [rape] prevention strategies need to show increased focus on the structural and social risk factors for rape. We now need to move towards a culture of preventing the perpetration of rape from ever occurring, rather than relying on prevention through responses.”
Findings from study on men and violence in Asia/Pacific
Half of the men who had perpetrated rape did so for the first time when they were teenagers (younger than 20).
Men’s reported perpetration of gang rape in their lifetime ranged from 1 percent to 14 percent across the nine sites.
Most men who had raped a man had also raped a female non-partner.
Rural Indonesia had the lowest prevalence of physical or sexual violence against partners (25 percent) reported by respondents, while Bougainville, PNG had the highest (80 percent).
Gang rape was the least common form of rape (4 percent average across the nine countries), except in Cambodia, where it was more common than non-partner rape by a man acting alone.
Forty-six percent of men who had ever been in a relationship reported having committed some form of violence or abuse against their partners.
Rural Bangladesh reported the lowest incidence of rape against female non-partners, at 3 percent, compared to a high of 27 percent in PNG.
In Indonesia, 26 percent of men said they had committed physical or sexual violence against partners, versus 80 percent in PNG.